So, the next time you watch Marlon Brando roar for Stella, don't just admire the method acting. Listen for the paper lantern tearing. Listen for the polka music that only Blanche hears (the sound of the night her husband killed himself). And when she walks out of that door, remember: she is not crazy. She is just too fragile for a world that worships Stanley.
And that is the most terrifying truth of all. Do you think Stella made the right choice? Is Blanche a sympathetic victim or a self-destructive parasite? Let me know in the comments. As for me, I’ll be in my living room, replacing the bare bulb with a Chinese lantern.
Williams is telling us the route of Blanche’s life: Desire (lust, longing, romantic yearning) led directly to Cemeteries (the suicide of her young husband, the loss of Belle Reve, the death of her family line), and that final destination is not heaven, but a rundown apartment where a beast waits. The title is the plot. The rest is just the screaming. Blanche is one of the most exhausting, irritating, and heartbreaking characters ever written. She lies about her drinking. She lies about her age. She lies about her past. She hides from light because light reveals truth, and truth reveals wrinkles, decay, and the fact that she was run out of the fictional town of Laurel, Mississippi, for having an affair with a seventeen-year-old student at the hotel she was living in.
Williams wrote the play as a queer man in the 1940s, living in a world that demanded he hide. Blanche is a coded portrait of the closeted self: performing gentility, terrified of being exposed, destroyed by the brute force of heteronormative masculinity. But you don’t need to be queer to feel the terror. You just need to have ever felt that the world is too loud, too bright, too real.
Her tragedy is not that she is a liar. Her tragedy is that she knows she is a liar, and she hates herself for it. Her famous line—“I don’t want realism. I want magic!”—is the mantra of the artist, the dreamer, the queer soul, and the survivor. She invents a fantasy not to deceive others, but to keep herself from drowning. If Blanche is the fading moon, Stanley is the brick thrown through the window.