Reviews for the album are generally positive but divided based on listener preference for her original acoustic style: Catchy & Polished
: Positive reviews highlight "pop gems" and praise her beautiful, strong vocals that manage to shine despite heavier production. Mixed Feelings on Production Marie Digby-Breathing Underwater full album zip
The album features a fuller, more produced sound that some critics described as "pop-laden" compared to her previous work. While her storytelling remains emotionally rich, the musical direction incorporates electronic elements and drum machines. Amazon.com Critical & Fan Reception Reviews for the album are generally positive but
: Some listeners felt the shift toward mainstream pop lacked the "charm and originality" of her debut, , at times calling the writing "bland" or "syrupy". Community Ratings Marie Digby-Breathing Underwater full album zip