| What would help | Why it matters | |-----------------|----------------| | (e.g., is it a novel, academic paper, report, etc.) | Gives context for tone, audience, and goals. | | Table of contents or list of major headings | Allows me to see the structure and pinpoint key sections to comment on. | | One or two representative excerpts (a paragraph or two) | Enables me to evaluate writing style, argument quality, and evidence. | | Specific aspects you’re interested in (e.g., plot, methodology, argument strength, readability, citation quality) | I can focus the review on what matters most to you. | | Any particular criteria you want used (e.g., clarity, originality, relevance, scholarly rigor) | Tailors the review to your standards. |
Here’s what would be most useful: